Ask Tosomitu About House Elves

I’m going to interpret Daniel’s first question narrowly (or else we’ll be here all day), as “Is it more or less ethical to create a house elf, relative to a human?” where by ‘house elf’ I mean a conscious, sentient being of approximately human intelligence with a psychology built around an essential need to serve humans and the enjoyment of doing so. (See Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets.)

For today’s purposes I’ll be staying agnostic about whether or not creating humans is a good thing (though I hear someone has written a book about it), and by extension whether or not you should start brewing up some magical servants.

Instead, I’ll take the decision to create something as a given. The only choice is human or elf.

Humans are on average more intrinsically valuable, in that they are more like me in their values, desires, ambitions, and relationships. (Though of course there are individual exceptions. I’d take Dobby over Jack the Ripper any day.)

House elves are on average more economically valuable. They are efficient, hard-working, and consume very little. Unlike humans, however, there don’t seem to be House elf outliers who have disproportionate economic impacts by inventing, creating art, or creating and running organizations.

With these factors in mind, it seems to clear to me that a mixed population of elves and humans is most desirable, so that they can take advantage of each others’ strengths. Whether marginal people should be elves or humans is pretty much down to economic conditions and the current elf/human ratio.

Second question: assuming house elves exist, is it ethical to use their labor? Yes of course. The alternative would make house elves miserable and benefit no one.

The Only Source Of Morality In The Universe delights in answering your real or hypothetical ethical dilemmas. Direct inquiries to asktosomitu@gmail.com.

Standard

4 thoughts on “Ask Tosomitu About House Elves

  1. gattsuru says:

    Tosomitu might be a reference I’m missing, but I don’t think the ethical concerns about the creation of slave species focus on economic value. Generally it’s more about deontology, virtue ethics, or to draw a hard line against Robin Hanson-esque catastrophes.

    House elves in Harry Potter present additional issues, as well. They’re somewhat unlikely to be present if we’re assuming an even marginally ethical slave race creator, though, and may be outside of the intended scope of Houck’s question

    Like

    • Acronym, “The Only Source Of Morality In The Universe.” I’m not a deontologist or virtue ethicist, so I don’t have much to say about those perspectives.

      In any case, House Elves are definitely not the optimal slave race, and I can imagine many scenarios where slave races are entirely unnecessary. (e.g. anything post-superintelligence, probably).

      Like

  2. John Costello says:

    The ability to turn humans into approximate house elves is one of the central plot macguffins in Stars in My Pocket Like Grains of Sand.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s